Click *H for Haydock Commentary. *Footnote for footnote etc.
Click any word in Latin Greek or Hebrew to activate the parser. Then click on the display to expand the parser.
*H Aleph. How is the gold become dim, the finest colour is changed, the stones of the sanctuary are scattered in the top of every street?
Ver. 1. Colour. Heb. "gold." Sept. "silver;" (H.) denoting the patriarchs, (Theod.) chiefs, (Vatab.) or ornaments of the temple. C. — It had formerly glittered with gold; now there was nothing but smoke and ruins. W.
*H Beth. The noble sons of Sion, and they that were clothed with the best gold: how are they esteemed as earthen vessels, the work of the potter's hands?
Ver. 2. Best. Heb. "gold of Phaz," in Colchis. Gen. ii. 11. C. — In Solomon's reign, they powdered their hair with gold dust. Jos. Ant. viii. 7. — Vessels. Is. xxx. 14.
*H Ghimel. Even the sea monsters have drawn out the breast, they have given suck to their young: the daughter of my people is cruel, like the ostrich in the desert.
Ver. 3. Sea-monsters. Lit. Lamia. Heb. Tannim. H. — The lamia has a face like a woman, and a body like beasts; and is cruel, yet feeds its young. W. — The fabulous lamia is supposed to destroy all children, (Diod. Sic. xx. Ovid. Fast. vi.) and cannot be meant. But the sea dog, though most cruel will not neglect its young ones. C. — Ostrich. Heb. henim, (H.) "swans." Is. xiii. 21. Job xxix. 14. The ostrich is said to break some of its eggs. Elian iv. 37. — Swans do the like, and devour their young; for which reason they are hated by the Indians. Elian xiv. 3. — Sept. "their young (drajohs) have suckled the daughters of my people, so that they can find no remedy, like," &c. H. — Though the ostrich has wings it never flies, but dwells in desert places. Such is the condition of the Israelites. Theodoret. — The ostrich forsakes its eggs. W. — All are solicitous for themselves.
*H He. They that were fed delicately have died in the streets: they that were brought up in scarlet have embraced the dung.
Ver. 5. Scarlet. Lit. "yellow;" croceis. H. — Heb. means purple. Those who have been educated in the most delicate manner, are forced to feed on the most disgusting things. 4 K. vi. 25. and xviii. 27. Deut. xxviii. 54.
* Footnotes
-
*
Genesis
19:4
But before they went to bed, the men of the city beset the house, both young and old, all the people together.
*H Vau. And the iniquity of the daughter of my people is made greater than the sin of Sodom, which was overthrown in a moment, and hands took nothing in her.
Ver. 6. In her. Sodom was destroyed by God. Her temporal misery was short. H. — Jerusalem was exposed to greater afflictions (C.) here, (H.) and her ingratitude and abominations were greater. Ezec. xvi. 46.
* Summa
*S Part 3, Ques 111, Article 4
[II-II, Q. 111, Art. 4]
Whether Hypocrisy Is Always a Mortal Sin?
Objection 1: It seems that hypocrisy is always a mortal sin. For Jerome says on Isa. 16:14: "Of the two evils it is less to sin openly than to simulate holiness": and a gloss on Job 1:21 [*St. Augustine, on Ps. 63:7], "As it hath pleased the Lord," etc., says that "pretended justice is no justice, but a twofold sin": and again a gloss on Lam. 4:6, "The iniquity . . . of my people is made greater than the sin of Sodom," says: "He deplores the sins of the soul that falls into hypocrisy, which is a greater iniquity than the sin of Sodom." Now the sins of Sodom are mortal sin. Therefore hypocrisy is always a mortal sin.
Obj. 2: Further, Gregory says (Moral. xxxi, 8) that hypocrites sin out of malice. But this is most grievous, for it pertains to the sin against the Holy Ghost. Therefore a hypocrite always sins mortally.
Obj. 3: Further, no one deserves the anger of God and exclusion from seeing God, save on account of mortal sin. Now the anger of God is deserved through hypocrisy according to Job 36:13, "Dissemblers and crafty men prove the wrath of God": and the hypocrite is excluded from seeing God, according to Job 13:16, "No hypocrite shall come before His presence." Therefore hypocrisy is always a mortal sin.
_On the contrary,_ Hypocrisy is lying by deed since it is a kind of dissimulation. But it is not always a mortal sin to lie by deed. Neither therefore is all hypocrisy a mortal sin.
Further, the intention of a hypocrite is to appear to be good. But this is not contrary to charity. Therefore hypocrisy is not of itself a mortal sin.
Further, hypocrisy is born of vainglory, as Gregory says (Moral. xxxi, 17). But vainglory is not always a mortal sin. Neither therefore is hypocrisy.
_I answer that,_ There are two things in hypocrisy, lack of holiness, and simulation thereof. Accordingly if by a hypocrite we mean a person whose intention is directed to both the above, one, namely, who cares not to be holy but only to appear so, in which sense Sacred Scripture is wont to use the term, it is evident that hypocrisy is a mortal sin: for no one is entirely deprived of holiness save through mortal sin. But if by a hypocrite we mean one who intends to simulate holiness, which he lacks through mortal sin, then, although he is in mortal sin, whereby he is deprived of holiness, yet, in his case, the dissimulation itself is not always a mortal sin, but sometimes a venial sin. This will depend on the end in view; for if this be contrary to the love of God or of his neighbor, it will be a mortal sin: for instance if he were to simulate holiness in order to disseminate false doctrine, or that he may obtain ecclesiastical preferment, though unworthy, or that he may obtain any temporal good in which he fixes his end. If, however, the end intended be not contrary to charity, it will be a venial sin, as for instance when a man takes pleasure in the pretense itself: of such a man it is said in _Ethic._ iv, 7 that "he would seem to be vain rather than evil"; for the same applies to simulation as to a lie.
It happens also sometimes that a man simulates the perfection of holiness which is not necessary for spiritual welfare. Simulation of this kind is neither a mortal sin always, nor is it always associated with mortal sin.
This suffices for the Replies to the Objections. _______________________
*H Zain. Her Nazarites were whiter than snow, purer than milk, more ruddy than the old ivory, fairer than the sapphire.
Ver. 7. Old ivory. Whiteness shews its age. Pliny iii. 8. — As it grows old it turns yellow, and loses much of its value. But the ancients had the art of dyeing it scarlet. Æneid xii. Iliad iv. Ovid ii. Am. v. C. — Heb. poninim may signify (H.) "pearls," the shells of which are stained with a delicate red; though the epithet ruddy may mean "shining," in which sense purpureus is used, Hor. iv. Od. 1. — The complexion of the Nazarites was fair, with a mixture of red. Cant. v. 10. They were probably clothed in white, and were highly respected. 1 Mac. iii. 49. Amos ii. 11. Num. vi. 18. C.
*H Heth. Their face is now made blacker than coals, and they are not known in the streets: their skin hath stuck to their bones, it is withered, and is become like wood.
Ver. 8. Coals. Heb. "blackness." Sept. "soot." H. — The people were naturally brown. Fasting and distress cause them to turn black. C. v. 10. Joel ii. 6. C. — They were so changed, that old acquaintances knew not one another. W.
*H Teth. It was better with them that were slain by the sword, than with them that died with hunger: for these pined away being consumed for want of the fruits of the earth.
Ver. 9. For. Lit. "by the barrenness of the earth." H. — Such a death was, no doubt, more painful than to perish quickly by the sword. C.
*H Jod. The hands of the pitiful women have sodden their own children: they were their meat in the destruction of the daughter of my people.
Ver. 10. Pitiful. So their nature dictates. W. — But hunger made them the reverse. Some think they slew their children, to prevent them being exposed to more cruel torments, (C.) as the people of Colchis do their sick. Chardin. — Sodden: boiled or roasted; coxerunt. v. 5. Deut. xxviii. 55. At the last siege of Jerusalem, this barbarity was manifested. C. Jos. Bel. vii. 8. Gr. 21. See C. ii. 20. — Daughter. So cities are styled. W.
*H Lamed. The kings of the earth, and all the inhabitants of the world would not have believed, that the adversary and the enemy should enter in by the gates of Jerusalem.
Ver. 12. Believed. God had so often protected this city against Sennacherib, Holofernes, &c. H. — It had been also so strongly fortified. 2 K. v. 6. C.
*H Mem. For the sins of her prophets, and the iniquities of her priests, that have shed the blood of the just in the midst of her.
Ver. 13. Priests. They too generally favoured (H.) the false prophets. C. ii. 26. &c. They were judges, and condemned the innocent: or exposed (C.) the citizens to destruction, by not warning them to amend, (H.) and to submit to the Chaldees. C. — Impostors are called prophets, as they have the same outward appearance. W.
*H Nun. They have wandered as blind men in the streets, they were defiled with blood: and when they could not help walking in it, they held up their skirts.
Ver. 14. They. Sept. "Her guards have tottered in," &c. — When. Prot. "so that men could not touch their garments," as they were defiled. H. — These hypocrites were afraid of touching blood, as they observed external ceremonies, while they disregarded the spirit of religion.
*H Samech. Depart you that are defiled, they cried out to them: Depart, get ye hence, touch not: for they quarrelled, and being removed, they said among the Gentiles: He will no more dwell among them.
Ver. 15. Depart. They were not ashamed to speak thus to others, or the citizens address the priests contaminated with blood. Even the Chaldees looked upon the Jews with abhorrence, as an abandoned people. — For they. Heb. "but they understood not, and wandered about. They, (C.) the Gentiles, said." H.
*H Phe. The face of the Lord hath divided them, he will no more regard them: they respected not the persons of the priests, neither had they pity on the ancient.
Ver. 16. They, the Jews; or rather the prophet thus describes the Chaldees. C. v. 12. Deut. xxviii. 50.
*H Ain. While we were yet standing, our eyes failed, expecting help for us in vain, when we looked attentively towards a nation that was not able to save.
Ver. 17. Save. The Egyptians attempted it in vain. C. xxxiv. 8. and xxxvii. 10.
*H Sade. Our steps have slipped in the way of our streets, our end draweth near: our days are fulfilled, for our end is come.
Ver. 18. Streets. There were enemies within as well as without. C.
*H Res. The breath of our mouth, Christ the Lord, is taken in our sins: to whom we said: Under thy shadow we shall live among the Gentiles.
Ver. 20. Christ, &c. According to the letter, is spoken of their king, who is called the Christ; that is, the anointed of the Lord. But is also relates, in the spiritual sense, to Christ our Lord, suffering for our sins. Ch. Is. liii. 5. S. Aug. de Civ. Dei. xviii. 33. — It literally speaks of Josias, or of Sedecias. W. — Josias was slain by the Egyptians. S. Jer. in Zac. xii. — But Sedecias seems chiefly to be meant. The people were much attached to him, though he was wicked; and they expected that he would have rescued them from the power of the Chaldees, as his league with the neighbouring Gentiles (C.) seemed to insure, (H.) if they had proved faithful. C. — But all was useless against the Lord. H.
*H Sin. Rejoice, and be glad, O daughter of Edom, that dwellest in the land of Hus: to thee also shall the cup come, thou shalt be made drunk, and naked.
Ver. 21. Rejoice. Edom had manifested her joy at the misfortunes of Juda. The prophet hints at this with a cutting irony. Ps. cxxxvi. 7. Abd. 11. — Come, as at a feast. Edom was visited five years after the Jews. C. xlix. 7. — Naked. Sept. "and shalt pour it out," (H.) or vomit. C. Grot.
*H Thau. Thy iniquity is accomplished, O daughter of Sion, he will no more carry thee away into captivity: he hath visited thy iniquity, O daughter of Edom, he hath discovered thy sins.
Ver. 22. Accomplished, and sufficiently punished by exile. C. l. 20. Is. xl. 2. — Discovered. Gen. xliv. 16. and 3 K. xvii. 18. C. — In vain wouldst thou hide them. H.